• Investing
  • Stock
Round Table Thoughts
  • Economy
  • Editor’s Pick
Home Economy Virginia judge uses slavery-era law to argue human embryos can be considered property
Economy

Virginia judge uses slavery-era law to argue human embryos can be considered property

by March 11, 2023
by March 11, 2023 0 comment
Share
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsapp

A Virginia judge determined that frozen human embryos are legally considered property, using a 19th century law regarding the treatment of slaves as the legal reasoning for his decision.

A preliminary opinion issued last month by Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Richard Gardiner is under scrutiny from lawyers who believe the judge wrongfully justified his decision based on measures from Virginia’s history when it was legally permissible to own human beings.

The ruling from Gardiner, a district court judge for the 19th Judicial District of Virginia, came amid a dispute between a divorced man and woman in which the ex-wife wants to use two frozen embryos the couple created when they were married to conceive another child.

‘It’s repulsive and it’s morally repugnant,’ Susan Crockin, a lawyer and scholar at Georgetown University’s Kennedy Institute of Ethics and an expert in reproductive technology law, told The Associated Press of the ruling.

Gardiner’s decision is not final as he has not yet ruled on other arguments in the case involving Honeyhline and Jason Heidemann, a divorced couple fighting over two frozen embryos that remain in storage.

Honeyhline, 45, wants to use the embryos, but her ex-husband Jason objects.

Initially, Gardiner sided with Jason. The law at the heart of the case governs how to divide ‘goods and chattels.’ The judge ruled that because embryos could not be bought or sold, they couldn’t be considered as such and therefore Honeyhline had no recourse under that law to claim custody of them.

But after the ex-wife’s lawyer, Adam Kronfeld, asked the judge to reconsider, Gardiner conducted a deep dive into the history of the law. He found that before the Civil War, it also applied to slaves. The judge then researched old rulings that governed custody disputes involving slaves, and said he found parallels that forced him to reconsider whether the law should apply to embryos.

In a separate part of his opinion, Gardiner also said he erred when he initially concluded that human embryos cannot be sold.

‘As there is no prohibition on the sale of human embryos, they may be valued and sold, and thus may be considered ‘goods or chattels,” he wrote.

Crockin said she’s not aware of any other judge in the U.S. who has concluded that human embryos can be bought and sold. She said the trend, if anything, has been to recognize that embryos have to be treated in a more nuanced way than as mere property.

Neither of the Heidemanns’ lawyers ever raised the slavery issue. They did raise other arguments in support of their cases, however.

Jason’s lawyers said allowing his ex-wife to implant the embryos they created when they were married ‘would force Mr. Heidemann to procreate against his wishes and therefore violate his constitutional right to procreational autonomy.’

Honeyhline’s lawyer argued that her right to the embryos outweighs her ex-husband’s objections, partly because he would have no legal obligations to be their parent and partly because she has no other options to conceive biological children after undergoing cancer treatments that made her infertile.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Kyle Morris covers politics for Fox News. Story tips can be sent to kyle.morris@fox.com and on Twitter: @RealKyleMorris.

This post appeared first on FOX NEWS
You Might Also Like
  • Biden issues memorandum to protect access to abortion pills
  • Missouri lawmakers try to strengthen abortion ban
  • Five Democrats who may retire ahead of 2024 Senate elections as GOP seeks control
  • Ohio train derailment: Rep. Omar calls out Buttigieg for ‘direct action,’ Vance says ‘many questions remain’
Share
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsapp

previous post
Daylight Saving Time: There oughta be a law
next post
MEM TV: Negative News Reverses Uptrend

You may also like

Morning Glory: Trump’s list of proposed key appointees he should...

February 27, 2024

AOC heckled, booed as NYC town hall descends into chaos

May 27, 2023

Democrats divided over ICC prosecutor seeking arrest warrants for Netanyahu,...

May 20, 2024

McConnell, Feinstein health scares spark new set of questions for...

September 6, 2023

Spy balloon likely sent extensive intelligence to China, experts say

February 6, 2023

Time for US to counter the bully at 30,000 feet

November 15, 2023

First lady Jill Biden invites Texas woman who sought illegal...

January 25, 2024

RFK Jr’s campaign renews Secret Service protection demand after FBI...

August 11, 2023

Portland city govt tells staff to avoid mentioning ‘pregnant women’...

July 9, 2023

Younger voters help boost Trump’s edge over Biden in latest...

December 19, 2023

    Stay updated with the latest news, exclusive offers, and special promotions. Sign up now and be the first to know! As a member, you'll receive curated content, insider tips, and invitations to exclusive events. Don't miss out on being part of something special.


    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.

    Recent Posts

    • Dick’s Sporting Goods stands by full-year guidance — even with tariffs looming

      May 28, 2025
    • Top Sectors to Watch + The 18 SMA Setup Every Trader Should Know

      May 28, 2025
    • Macy’s CEO says retailer will hike some prices as tariffs cut into profits

      May 28, 2025
    • 23andMe to delist from Nasdaq, deregister with SEC

      May 28, 2025
    • Walmart fined for shipping realistic toy guns to New York, violating state law

      May 28, 2025

    Popular Posts

    • 1

      Trump-era China sanctions ended by Biden may be...

      June 27, 2024 2,763 views
    • 2

      Walz’s honeymoon with China gets fresh scrutiny as...

      August 9, 2024 2,470 views
    • 3

      Biden appointee played key role in recruiting Chinese...

      June 25, 2024 2,449 views
    • 4

      Shein’s global ambitions leaves some cybersecurity experts fearful...

      July 10, 2024 2,427 views
    • 5

      Harris VP pick spent years promoting research facility...

      August 29, 2024 2,305 views

    Categories

    • Economy (7,009)
    • Editor's Pick (2,101)
    • Investing (538)
    • Stock (2,576)

    Popular Posts

    • 1

      Trump-era China sanctions ended by Biden may be revived under new House GOP bill

      June 27, 2024
    • 2

      Walz’s honeymoon with China gets fresh scrutiny as Harris camp blasts ‘lying’ critics

      August 9, 2024
    • 3

      Biden appointee played key role in recruiting Chinese businesses to Delaware: ‘Longtime friends’

      June 25, 2024
    • 4

      Shein’s global ambitions leaves some cybersecurity experts fearful of Chinese spy threats

      July 10, 2024
    • 5

      Harris VP pick spent years promoting research facility that collaborated with ‘Chinese military company’

      August 29, 2024

    Latest News

    • Dick’s Sporting Goods stands by full-year guidance — even with...

      May 28, 2025
    • Top Sectors to Watch + The 18 SMA Setup Every...

      May 28, 2025
    • Macy’s CEO says retailer will hike some prices as tariffs...

      May 28, 2025

    Categories

    • Economy (7,009)
    • Editor's Pick (2,101)
    • Investing (538)
    • Stock (2,576)

    Disclaimer: RoundTableThoughts.com, its managers, its employees, and assigns (collectively “The Company”) do not make any guarantee or warranty about what is advertised above. Information provided by this website is for research purposes only and should not be considered as personalized financial advice. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. Any investments recommended here should be taken into consideration only after consulting with your investment advisor and after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

    Copyright © 2024 RoundTableThoughts.com. All Rights Reserved.

    Round Table Thoughts
    • Investing
    • Stock
    Round Table Thoughts
    • Economy
    • Editor’s Pick

    Read alsox

    Marjorie Taylor Greene announces bill to...

    June 13, 2023

    White House, family offer conflicting accounts...

    July 22, 2024

    Fetterman scolds Dem colleagues for failing...

    April 19, 2024
    Sign In

    Keep me signed in until I sign out

    Forgot your password?

    Password Recovery

    A new password will be emailed to you.

    Have received a new password? Login here