• Investing
  • Stock
Round Table Thoughts
  • Economy
  • Editor’s Pick
Home Economy Supreme Court sharply divided over enforcing municipal homeless camping ban
Economy

Supreme Court sharply divided over enforcing municipal homeless camping ban

by April 23, 2024
by April 23, 2024 0 comment
Share
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsapp

The Supreme Court appeared deeply at odds on Monday over a small city’s ban on homeless people sleeping in public places, with emotional statements from the bench over society’s competing civic responsibilities.  

It comes as jurisdictions across the nation – but especially in the West – struggle with a record double-digit surge in the homeless population.

The current appeal comes from officials in Grants Pass, Oregon, with almost 40,000 residents. 

Municipal ordinances there ban sleeping or camping on streets, under bridges and in parks or other publicly owned property. The ban includes the use of bedding, pillows, cardboard boxes, sleeping bags, stoves or fires – with fines starting at $295.

At issue is whether the enforcement of generally applicable laws regulating camping on public property – but targeting the unhoused – constitute ‘cruel and unusual punishment’ prohibited by the Eighth Amendment.

The city argues its policies are fairly enforced, banning camping for everyone on public land. But homeless advocates say it criminalizes those who live outdoors without a stable place to call home.

In the contentious two-and-a-half hours of arguments, the justices repeatedly questioned whether the city’s law banned conduct or status – just camping on public property vs. the larger situation of being homeless.

‘Your ordinance goes way beyond that,’ said Justice Elena Kagan. ‘Your statute says that person cannot take himself and himself only, and can’t take a blanket and sleep someplace without it being a crime… It seems like you’re criminalizing a status.’

But others on the bench said these difficult on-the-ground discretionary decisions should best be left out of the hands of judges.

‘Municipalities have competing priorities,’ said Chief Justice John Roberts. ‘What if there are lead pipes in the water? Do you build the homeless shelter or do you take care of the lead pipes? Why would you think these nine people [on the court] are the best to weigh those policy judgments?’

Cities across the country will watch how the nine justices rule on this balancing act between helping the misfortunate with a range of public benefits vs. the financial and social costs associated, including crime, mental health and sanitation concerns. 

San Francisco in an amicus brief said it spent over $672 million last year to provide shelter and housing for the homeless, but public encampments continue to grow. The city says its inability to enforce its own laws ‘has made it more difficult to provide services’ to that population. 

About 600 people are estimated to be involuntarily unsheltered in Grants Pass, a scenic area surrounded by the Klamath Mountains in the southwest part of the state along the Rogue River.

City leaders have expressed frustration about not being able to open an appropriate government-run indoor shelter space, citing a variety of competing community views over funding, size and location.

To fill the gap, nonprofit and religious volunteers provide hot food and health care in the unhoused community, in areas like Tussing Park, which is dotted with picnic benches and landscaping. 

The privately operated Grants Pass Gospel Rescue Mission offers immediate and long-term assistance. And the Mobile Integrative Navigation Team (MINT) provides free transportation for medical care and other vital services. 

In its appeal to the high court, the city says its enforcement scheme ‘does not prohibit modest fines and short jail terms, which are neither cruel nor unusual by any established measure, for camping on public property.’

It said a federal appeals court ruling striking down its laws, ‘prevents governments from proactively addressing the serious social policy problems associated with the homelessness crisis, and calls into doubt many other criminal prohibitions.’

But lawyers for homeless individuals and support organizations say singling out and criminalizing this vulnerable population is not the answer, and only creates more civic problems for everyone.  

‘There is simply no place in Grants Pass for them to find affordable housing or shelter,’ said the United Community Action Network, a nonprofit group that serves homeless people in Josephine County. ‘They are not choosing to live on the street or in the woods.’

Local residents say the encampments create unsafe and unhealthy conditions.

‘Families are afraid to go to the parks,’ said Brock Spurgeon. ‘And it’s not just the campers or the homeless. It’s the drug use and the vandalism and the excessive littering. Needles on the ground, broken meth pipes on the ground. So no one wants to take their kids anymore.’

In court arguments, every justice agreed the homeless problem was serious and needed to be addressed immediately, but there were disagreements over how and who should tackle it.

‘Before extending a constitutional precedent, we usually think about whether state or local law already achieves those purposes, so that the federal courts aren’t micromanaging the homeless policy,’ said Justice Brett Kavanaugh. ‘And it’s on a daily basis, when you work with the homeless… how many people are going to show up to the food bank.’

But Justice Sonia Sotomayor suggested the city here failed in that basic civic responsibility.

‘The intent is to remove every homeless person and give them no public space to sit down with a blanket or fall asleep with a blanket,’ she said. ‘Where do we put them when every city, every village, every town lacks compassion? If they pass a law identical to this, where are they supposed to sleep? Are they supposed to kill themselves [by] not sleeping?’  

The homeless population in the U.S. rose 12% last year to its highest level, according to a federal Housing and Urban Development (HUD). That is about 653,000 people in the January 2023 snapshot study.

California, Washington, Florida and New York represent more than half the homeless population, with California alone comprising 28%, according to the HUD study. 

Officials cite a dramatic rise in rents, as well as a drop in coronavirus pandemic-related public assistance.

The Justice Department is supporting neither party in the Grants Pass case, but says a federal appeals court properly concluded ordinances punishing people for sleeping outside where there is insufficient shelter space are unconstitutional. But it added that applying its ruling to all homeless people was wrong, ‘without requiring a more particularized inquiry into the circumstances of the individuals to whom those ordinances may be applied.’

The key to resolving this case could be how the Supreme Court applies its 1962 precedent in Robinson v. California. There, the justices concluded the Eighth Amendment’s ban on ‘cruel and unusual punishment’ prevents cities from criminalizing a person’s drug status – for simply being an ‘addict.’ But states could prosecute drug ‘conduct’ – buying, selling or possession of narcotics.

The case is City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson (23-175).

This post appeared first on FOX NEWS
You Might Also Like
  • Hunter’s ex-business associate blasts Biden’s new claim about son’s business dealings: ‘Complete malarkey’
  • ‘Money guy’: This Hunter Biden business partner could blow the lid off Biden family’s business dealings
  • Lightfoot’s election loss should serve as ‘wake-up call’ for other left-wing mayors, political insiders say
  • Schumer calls on Xi to support Israel as China says relation with US ‘will determine the future of humanity’
Share
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsapp

previous post
Papua New Guinea leader blasts Biden for claiming his uncle was eaten by cannibals
next post
Biden admin notes ‘urgent’ concern over Israel in Gaza human rights report

You may also like

YouTube says it removed Jordan Peterson interview of RFK Jr....

June 20, 2023

Haley, Christie stay quiet on Trump guilty verdict as GOP...

June 5, 2024

Biden calls for ‘more action’ after Texas mall shooting, asks...

May 8, 2023

Defiant fisherman tells Chinese coast guard to ‘go away’ from...

January 24, 2024

Solana and Cardano: Cardano at a new September high

September 26, 2024

How presidential battleground states have changed over the years

February 20, 2024

White House sheds no new light on Biden docs scandal...

January 24, 2023

Manchin, Tester staff are the least diverse among Senate Democrats,...

July 15, 2023

Kamala Harris to accept presidential nomination on final night of...

August 22, 2024

Solana and Cardano: Cardano drops to new weekly low

October 24, 2024

YouTube says it removed Jordan Peterson interview of RFK Jr....

June 20, 2023

Haley, Christie stay quiet on Trump guilty verdict as GOP...

June 5, 2024

Biden calls for ‘more action’ after Texas mall shooting, asks...

May 8, 2023

Defiant fisherman tells Chinese coast guard to ‘go away’ from...

January 24, 2024

Solana and Cardano: Cardano at a new September high

September 26, 2024

How presidential battleground states have changed over the years

February 20, 2024

White House sheds no new light on Biden docs scandal...

January 24, 2023

Manchin, Tester staff are the least diverse among Senate Democrats,...

July 15, 2023

Kamala Harris to accept presidential nomination on final night of...

August 22, 2024

Solana and Cardano: Cardano drops to new weekly low

October 24, 2024

    Stay updated with the latest news, exclusive offers, and special promotions. Sign up now and be the first to know! As a member, you'll receive curated content, insider tips, and invitations to exclusive events. Don't miss out on being part of something special.


    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.

    Recent Posts

    • Cargo thieves are attacking the U.S. supply chain at alarming rates

      May 10, 2025
    • Where the Market Goes Next: Key Resistance Levels + Top Bullish Stocks to Watch Now

      May 10, 2025
    • Recession Ahead? Sector Rotation Model Warns of Rising Risk

      May 10, 2025
    • Investment Portfolio Feeling Stagnant? Transform Your Path Today

      May 9, 2025
    • Confused by the Market? Let the Traffic Light Indicator Guide You

      May 9, 2025

    Popular Posts

    • 1

      Trump-era China sanctions ended by Biden may be...

      June 27, 2024 2,634 views
    • 2

      Walz’s honeymoon with China gets fresh scrutiny as...

      August 9, 2024 2,339 views
    • 3

      Biden appointee played key role in recruiting Chinese...

      June 25, 2024 2,322 views
    • 4

      Shein’s global ambitions leaves some cybersecurity experts fearful...

      July 10, 2024 2,303 views
    • 5

      Harris VP pick spent years promoting research facility...

      August 29, 2024 2,186 views

    Categories

    • Economy (7,009)
    • Editor's Pick (2,067)
    • Investing (538)
    • Stock (2,536)

    Popular Posts

    • 1

      Trump-era China sanctions ended by Biden may be revived under new House GOP bill

      June 27, 2024
    • 2

      Walz’s honeymoon with China gets fresh scrutiny as Harris camp blasts ‘lying’ critics

      August 9, 2024
    • 3

      Biden appointee played key role in recruiting Chinese businesses to Delaware: ‘Longtime friends’

      June 25, 2024
    • 4

      Shein’s global ambitions leaves some cybersecurity experts fearful of Chinese spy threats

      July 10, 2024
    • 5

      Harris VP pick spent years promoting research facility that collaborated with ‘Chinese military company’

      August 29, 2024

    Latest News

    • Cargo thieves are attacking the U.S. supply chain at alarming...

      May 10, 2025
    • Where the Market Goes Next: Key Resistance Levels + Top...

      May 10, 2025
    • Recession Ahead? Sector Rotation Model Warns of Rising Risk

      May 10, 2025

    Categories

    • Economy (7,009)
    • Editor's Pick (2,067)
    • Investing (538)
    • Stock (2,536)

    Disclaimer: RoundTableThoughts.com, its managers, its employees, and assigns (collectively “The Company”) do not make any guarantee or warranty about what is advertised above. Information provided by this website is for research purposes only and should not be considered as personalized financial advice. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. Any investments recommended here should be taken into consideration only after consulting with your investment advisor and after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

    Copyright © 2024 RoundTableThoughts.com. All Rights Reserved.

    Round Table Thoughts
    • Investing
    • Stock
    Round Table Thoughts
    • Economy
    • Editor’s Pick

    Read alsox

    2024 Divide: Republican presidential candidates spar...

    October 12, 2023

    Mideast oil powerhouse bans Russian ‘shadow...

    August 14, 2024

    Electoral College changes could put Trump...

    May 10, 2024
    Sign In

    Keep me signed in until I sign out

    Forgot your password?

    Password Recovery

    A new password will be emailed to you.

    Have received a new password? Login here